Is Buying a New or Used Tiller Worth It?

Is Buying a New or Used Tiller Worth It?

New vs Used Tillers

Whether you’re a gardener or a small-scale farmer, it means that you’re a planner.

When seed catalogs arrive in your mailbox months before spring, it doesn’t surprise you, because you anticipated them for weeks.

Crops aren’t the only detail you’ll have to plan, though. After taking stock of the tools you need for the upcoming year, you need a garden tiller that works.

Just like seeds, your tools are an investment of your time and money. If you’re like most people, you’re tired of renting or repairing tools. But there’s a question we hear often from the lawn and garden planners we know: Should I buy a used or new rototiller?

Determine the Type of Tiller to Buy

For gardeners and farmers, the most important question to ask applies to both new and used tillers: What are you using it for?

There are three main types of tillers. The question above will help you select the right tool for the job:

  • Rear-tine tillers provide a lot of power. Because the wheels pass over the soil before the tines do, these tillers compact the soil less. They’re great for improving the soil in large plots and breaking ground in plots being tilled for the first time.

  • Front-tine tillers tend to be smaller and lighter than rear-tine tillers. That makes them better suited for tilling small plots and working compost and other amendments into soil that’s been tilled before.

  • Cultivators help stir and aerate soil and remove weeds from your garden plot. They’re ideal for maintaining or improving soil at the start of or during the growing season.

Many gardeners prefer to till or cultivate their soil annually. When it comes to tackling tasks on a regular schedule, there’s a sentiment we’ve heard: Having the tools for the task ready makes the work less of a burden and more of a joy.  

Buying a tiller allows you, the planner, to be ready to enjoy healthy garden soil every year. Whether you buy either a used tiller or a new tiller simply depends on your needs. So, let’s explore whether buying new or used is worth it for you.

Buying a Used Tiller 

Used vs New TillersBuying a used garden tiller involves a number of steps. Like growing seed, shopping for the right garden tools requires time, patience, and attention to several details:

  • Availability
  • Condition
  • Payment
  • Transport

Research What’s Available

Your first step when choosing to buy a used rototiller is to see what used tillers are available for sale. There are two sources that people commonly check for secondhand garden equipment:

  • Online marketplaces, like eBay or Craig's List
  • Local sellers, including family, friends, neighbors, and resale shops

When shopping for used tools on an online marketplace, you can never truly know the condition the piece is in. If it's broken, the cost to ship it back might not be worth the purchase.

Additionally, in either case, your selection will be limited to what’s available on the market at the time, so be careful to choose only the kind of equipment you need. If you’re looking for a lightweight tool to help you weed your modest vegetable garden, you won’t be satisfied with your purchase of a rear-tine tiller.

Once you’ve found a used garden tiller you like, you can contact the seller to learn more about it.

Examine the Tiller’s Condition 

Perhaps the most important step in buying a used tiller is to determine what kind of wear and tear might be present. A tiller can show several signs of heavy usage and even significant damage:

  • Dirty engine oil containing metal specks:
    Damage, overuse, and poor maintenance
  • Low or burnt transmission oil:
    Transmission at the end of its life
  • Smoke:
    Worn pistons, valves, or seals
  • Rust spots and flaking paint: 
    Tiller is old or has been left outside
  • Bent, dull, or broken tines:
    Improper usage or maintenance
  • Carburetor metering systems clogged with gasoline or cracked gas lines: 
    Improper storage, old fuel, or a gummed-up carburetor that's hard to fix
  • Grinding noises from the engine: 
    Failing parts
  • An engine that won’t start:
    Several possible problems, including a failed spark plug, a broken recoil starter, and even an engine that needs to be completely replaced

Inspecting the tiller is easier in person. If you’re talking with an online seller, you’ll have to rely on any information the seller can provide, including photos, to help you decide whether to make the purchase. Don’t be afraid to ask questions about any of the parts listed above.

To Fix or Not to Fix? 

The problems on a used tiller might be readily visible, like broken tines, or they might be harder to see, like a worn spark plug. Any of the signs of damage listed above could be a reason why a seller is giving up his or her tiller in the first place. 

That doesn't mean that buying a damaged tiller is necessarily a bad idea. Even if you choose not to repair the tiller, the seller might offer it for a lower price or even for free. You then can use it as a collection of spare parts to fix the tiller you eventually do buy and use.


Pay for Your Tiller 

Once you’re satisfied with the condition of the tiller and the price the seller’s offering for it, you’re ready to make a purchase.

A purchase of a used piece of machinery is no small event. It requires a leap of faith. That leap is easy to take when you’re paying money to someone you know, like a family member or trusted neighbor whom you can hold accountable.

If you’re buying your used rototiller from an online seller, make sure that your leap is supported by a verified, reputable payment system.

Bring Your Tiller Home 

After you’ve paid for your tiller, it’s time to transport it to your home or to the small garden or plot where you’ll use it. This involves a couple of considerations:

  • If you’ve bought your tiller from a local seller, make sure you’ve considered how you’ll get it home—either in your own vehicle or, if your vehicle is small, in a rental truck or van, or with the help of a utility trailer.
  • If you’ve bought your tiller from an online seller, make sure you’ve factored the cost of shipping into the price you pay, and check that you’ll be able to track your shipment.

Like the other steps in buying a used tiller, transporting your tiller takes time and effort. Once it’s done, however, you have a tiller that you can take home and begin to repair (perhaps after doing a little research on maintenance) so that you can eventually get to work.

Buying a New Tiller 

New Garden Tillers at Mowers DirectUnlike buying a used tiller, buying a new tiller from a retailer offers one clear advantage: You’re getting a tool in guaranteed pristine condition, one that gives back and will last you for years.

Because shopping for a new product is almost the same process no matter what the product is, shopping for a new tiller becomes less of a question of what steps you need to take and more of a question of what selling points and additional benefits are at your disposal:

  • Available selection
  • Prices, sales, and discounts
  • Shipping options
  • Product support and knowledge
  • Manuals
  • Warranties

Available Selection

Retailers that list new tillers for sale offer plenty of tiller models—and usually will have several of each model in stock. Take advantage of the wide selection to choose a new tiller that meets your exact specifications and needs. Remember: rear-tine tillers, front-tine tillers, and cultivators are not all the same!

Prices, Sales, and Discounts

A few hundred dollars on garden equipment is a large expense to consider. However, because of how quickly prices change in the resale market, the price of used rototillers and new rototillers often turns out to be the same.

Additionally, retailers that sell new tillers are able to negotiate and work directly with vendors and manufacturers to provide you with sales and factory direct deals throughout the year.


Shipping Options

New tiller retailers usually have shipping options intended to make receiving your new cultivator or tiller easy and convenient.

At Mowers Direct, we provide free shipping on most tillers and cultivators to the 48 contiguous United States. Products usually ship within a matter of days, and shipment tracking is provided for your peace of mind.

Product Support, Knowledge, Manuals, and Warranties

Retailers who sell new garden cultivators and tillers want to make sure that you’re happy with your purchase. That’s why they support your purchase in several handy ways:

  • Product experts with first-hand experience and personalized advice:  
    Help you make an educated choice
  • Product knowledge, including buyer’s guides and troubleshooting guides:  
    Allow you to fully understand how to use your tiller
  • Extensive product warranties:
    Make sure damage is covered
  • Access to product manuals:
    Help with repairs and maintenance
  • Trusted and easy-to-verify reputations with customer feedback and reviews: 
    Make you feel secure about your purchase

Before buying your new tiller, take some time to see what forms of support the retailer offers. Even if you don’t use them, you might find that the peace of mind a customer support line or a series of how-to tips gives you makes buying a new tiller a worthwhile purchase.

Not Quite New: Buying Scratch and Dent Tillers

New vs Used and Scratch and Dent TillersIf the initial cost of new tillers still has you worried, but you find yourself even more concerned about the maintenance and uncertainty with used tillers, you have another option.

Mowers Direct offers scratch and dent tillers and cultivators. These tools have cosmetic damage but are still new and mechanically sound. Lucky for you, that cosmetic damage can save you a pretty penny.

Is Buying New Really Beneficial?

Buying any piece of equipment is an investment. Investments are tools for people who like to plan. With your own tiller, new or used, not only will you be ready to tend your soil whenever the need arises; you’ll be ready to watch your garden grow. And with a brand-new tiller in your shed or garage, you can plan to enjoy healthy garden soil for many years ahead.

Forward-thinking gardeners tend to have the tools they need in place so that when it comes time to work, there’s no delay, no last-minute surprises, just hours to focus on the task at hand.

Money might not buy you happiness, but having your tiller ready, season after season, just might.

NEXT: Tiller Coupons and Discounts

Dale, the Power Equipment Expert
Power Equipment Expert
Was this article helpful?